Comments on: Trials And Tribble-ations – 2nd Edition http://fanedit.org/252/ The wonderful world of movies - edited by fans for fans Thu, 09 Feb 2012 21:32:36 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: ionvox http://fanedit.org/252/comment-page-1/#comment-11964 ionvox Wed, 10 Aug 2011 00:22:33 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=314#comment-11964 I would love to see and review this. But sadly, there doesn't seem to be any form of download any more. Ah well. I would love to see and review this. But sadly, there doesn’t seem to be any form of download any more. Ah well.

]]> By: flyboy707 http://fanedit.org/252/comment-page-1/#comment-10574 flyboy707 Mon, 14 Dec 2009 19:37:52 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=314#comment-10574 I perfer this edit more than Pauley79's because of the qaulity of the edit. Overall. 9/10. I did find the black screen transitions a little disjointed, but undertsand why they are used. I agree also, that I found this story much less satisfying than I expected/wanted to. It is NOT because of the edit, just that I can't reconcile that Sisko is re-telling the events to the temproal agents and not experiencing real-time. How could he possibly know and be able to re-tell what the original crew is doing (except for the parts he/his crew experiences? of course, I guess he could be relating the histroicla account, inter-weaved with his own to the tmeproal agents - but wouldn't they know the histroical version already? An excelelnt edit overall. I perfer this edit more than Pauley79’s because of the qaulity of the edit. Overall. 9/10. I did find the black screen transitions a little disjointed, but undertsand why they are used.

I agree also, that I found this story much less satisfying than I expected/wanted to. It is NOT because of the edit, just that I can’t reconcile that Sisko is re-telling the events to the temproal agents and not experiencing real-time. How could he possibly know and be able to re-tell what the original crew is doing (except for the parts he/his crew experiences? of course, I guess he could be relating the histroicla account, inter-weaved with his own to the tmeproal agents – but wouldn’t they know the histroical version already?

An excelelnt edit overall.

]]> By: Ripplin http://fanedit.org/252/comment-page-1/#comment-10305 Ripplin Sat, 24 Oct 2009 18:25:56 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=314#comment-10305 Always good to see more Trek edits around, and this is a fun one, using two of the most loved episodes of Star Trek and DS9. The execution isn't perfect, but I don't know that it ever could be, for reasons previosuly explained by others. Still, a great watch. Thanks! :) Always good to see more Trek edits around, and this is a fun one, using two of the most loved episodes of Star Trek and DS9. The execution isn’t perfect, but I don’t know that it ever could be, for reasons previosuly explained by others. Still, a great watch. Thanks! :)

]]> By: col.hutty http://fanedit.org/252/comment-page-1/#comment-10029 col.hutty Thu, 30 Jul 2009 14:34:27 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=314#comment-10029 I am an extended edition buff and have a big collection of original ones and all the fanedits from here. Many extended editions do not add anything to the movie, just add more useless scenes. I will rate the ones here. Rating criteria: image quality, sound quality, 3x improvement, overall. Image Quality: 7 of 10 Sound Quality: 6 of 10 Improvement: 7 of 10 Overall: 7 of 10 I am an extended edition buff and have a big collection of original ones and all the fanedits from here.
Many extended editions do not add anything to the movie, just add more useless scenes. I will rate the ones here.
Rating criteria: image quality, sound quality, 3x improvement, overall.
Image Quality: 7 of 10
Sound Quality: 6 of 10
Improvement: 7 of 10
Overall: 7 of 10

]]> By: blackhawk http://fanedit.org/252/comment-page-1/#comment-4332 blackhawk Tue, 29 Apr 2008 19:57:12 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=314#comment-4332 I think this was well done in the integration of the complete original tribble episode into the DS9 tribble episode. However, strictly as a story, I didn't find it as satisfying as I expected. I think the problem, for me, was one of shifting viewpoints. The story still uses the DS9 episode as the main framework, but that makes the shifts to the viewpoints of the original cast jarring since there is no story justification for the change. How can Sisko be telling the agents of Temporal Affairs about conversations between the original episode cast to which none of the DS9 characters were witness? I do think it was an interesting attempt but, for me at least, it did not quite work. I think this was well done in the integration of the complete original tribble episode into the DS9 tribble episode. However, strictly as a story, I didn’t find it as satisfying as I expected. I think the problem, for me, was one of shifting viewpoints. The story still uses the DS9 episode as the main framework, but that makes the shifts to the viewpoints of the original cast jarring since there is no story justification for the change. How can Sisko be telling the agents of Temporal Affairs about conversations between the original episode cast to which none of the DS9 characters were witness? I do think it was an interesting attempt but, for me at least, it did not quite work.

]]> By: PJayBe http://fanedit.org/252/comment-page-1/#comment-4331 PJayBe Tue, 22 Apr 2008 19:56:33 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=314#comment-4331 Fantastic "edittion" of this fine episode. Really well done. However, I cannot get the artwork to download.............. Philip Fantastic “edittion” of this fine episode. Really well done.

However, I cannot get the artwork to download…………..

Philip

]]>