Comments on: The Fifth Element Prime Evil Edition http://fanedit.org/279/ The wonderful world of movies - edited by fans for fans Thu, 11 Mar 2010 12:11:28 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: r8s8fr8 http://fanedit.org/279/comment-page-1/#comment-10461 r8s8fr8 Fri, 27 Nov 2009 17:46:17 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=101#comment-10461 I love the original and this one was not bad, but in my opinion weaker. I love the original and this one was not bad, but in my opinion weaker.

]]> By: ThrowgnCpr http://fanedit.org/279/comment-page-1/#comment-4929 ThrowgnCpr Fri, 23 May 2008 21:38:37 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=101#comment-4929 I really enjoyed this edit. I think that it works very well as it is cut. Voodl has done a great job. The audio and video are quite nice, and thanks to boon23 we have a really nice DVD authored & cover art to accompany this nice edit. I really liked that Tucker's character has been greatly reduced. It allows the focus back to the story and makes it a much more enjoyable film. I recommend this to all. 5 of 5 I really enjoyed this edit. I think that it works very well as it is cut. Voodl has done a great job. The audio and video are quite nice, and thanks to boon23 we have a really nice DVD authored & cover art to accompany this nice edit. I really liked that Tucker’s character has been greatly reduced. It allows the focus back to the story and makes it a much more enjoyable film. I recommend this to all. 5 of 5

]]> By: azzrael http://fanedit.org/279/comment-page-1/#comment-4928 azzrael Sun, 03 Jun 2007 01:11:55 +0000 http://fanedit.org/wpTF/?p=101#comment-4928 this edit removes two aspects of the original movie: - Removal of tucker character as the DJ Although his performance as an actor is good and neatly performed , and the character is the comic relief for the movie. Why does it feel good to remove him? In my opinion two reasons: reason number two: the part is too much "overdone" the various lines , the body language , the costumes (i mean look at his hair!), too much is too much. reason number one: whenever he talks he is shouting. The tone of his voice *does not* suit a comic relief character. And that's that. - Removal of the ancient prophecy This changes the story , shortens the movie , in an attempt to make the threat more mysterious. In my opinion fails uterly. Because the threat is not visible anymore. The watching experience of his fanedit is not as enjoyable as all other fanedit I've seen. In my opinion it's because the "threat" has been tampered with , thus the balance for the story told is upset. (imho) technical review: It's a boon23 quality standard. nuff said ;-) this edit removes two aspects of the original movie:
- Removal of tucker character as the DJ
Although his performance as an actor is good and neatly performed , and the character is the comic relief for the movie. Why does it feel good to remove him?
In my opinion two reasons:
reason number two: the part is too much “overdone” the various lines , the body language , the costumes (i mean look at his hair!), too much is too much.
reason number one: whenever he talks he is shouting. The tone of his voice *does not* suit a comic relief character. And that’s that.

- Removal of the ancient prophecy
This changes the story , shortens the movie , in an attempt to make the threat more mysterious.
In my opinion fails uterly. Because the threat is not visible anymore.

The watching experience of his fanedit is not as enjoyable as all other fanedit I’ve seen. In my opinion it’s because the “threat” has been tampered with , thus the balance for the story told is upset.
(imho)

technical review:
It’s a boon23 quality standard. nuff said ;-)

]]>