Comments on: Star Wars: Episode 1 – Balance of the Force http://fanedit.org/5140/ The wonderful world of movies - edited by fans for fans Thu, 09 Feb 2012 21:32:36 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: TMBTM http://fanedit.org/5140/comment-page-1/#comment-10890 TMBTM Sun, 11 Apr 2010 12:28:16 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=5140#comment-10890 This was one of the first fanedit I ever seen and must say that the Jar Jar subtitle were a real treat to me as they intriduced sme nice subplot explaining things. Now I can see that it's not a perfect edit, but still, very interesting and worth the download IMO. This was one of the first fanedit I ever seen and must say that the Jar Jar subtitle were a real treat to me as they intriduced sme nice subplot explaining things. Now I can see that it’s not a perfect edit, but still, very interesting and worth the download IMO.

]]> By: Tal http://fanedit.org/5140/comment-page-1/#comment-10750 Tal Tue, 02 Feb 2010 13:04:24 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=5140#comment-10750 I have to say I really enjoyed this, mainly because the real version was such a huge disappointment and this was such a vast improvement on it. Jar-Jar saying "Go, you little bastard!" as Anakin finally gets his pod moving at the race really made me laugh. Actually I'd like to know what is the difference between this edit and "The Phantom Re-edit" that I see mentioned on another page here? I have to say I really enjoyed this, mainly because the real version was such a huge disappointment and this was such a vast improvement on it. Jar-Jar saying “Go, you little bastard!” as Anakin finally gets his pod moving at the race really made me laugh.

Actually I’d like to know what is the difference between this edit and “The Phantom Re-edit” that I see mentioned on another page here?

]]> By: jokersmailbag http://fanedit.org/5140/comment-page-1/#comment-9534 jokersmailbag Wed, 01 Apr 2009 14:50:06 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=5140#comment-9534 Interesting ideas for sure. The execution could be a lot better. It has quite a bit of problems, mostly audio for me. The new languages are a fantastic idea but really don't come close to working, being clearly the non-english tracks played mostly backward. This causes strange drop offs at the ends (beginnings) of phrases. Jar Jar is a bit more tolerable, but still far too many antics. And having him swear? Just doesn't fit, IMO. It was explained to me that this edit was made a few years ago and just now released officially here on FE. Some of the technical problems with this edit were more or less common to most fanedits at the time- so I have factored this in to consideration here. Still... With so many good ideas, it would be great to see an improved version of this. Interesting ideas for sure. The execution could be a lot better. It has quite a bit of problems, mostly audio for me. The new languages are a fantastic idea but really don’t come close to working, being clearly the non-english tracks played mostly backward. This causes strange drop offs at the ends (beginnings) of phrases.

Jar Jar is a bit more tolerable, but still far too many antics. And having him swear? Just doesn’t fit, IMO.

It was explained to me that this edit was made a few years ago and just now released officially here on FE. Some of the technical problems with this edit were more or less common to most fanedits at the time- so I have factored this in to consideration here. Still…

With so many good ideas, it would be great to see an improved version of this.

]]>