Comments on: Star Wars: Twilight of the Republic

By: amatar

amatar — Sat, 03 Jul 2010 22:24:23 +0000

Well, I downloaded JasonN’s versions of Phantom Menace and RotS and I absolutely LOVED them.

Sadly, I will not be downloading this edit, as the whole death of his mother/Sandpeople slaughter being cut from the movie is a dealbreaker for me.

As p3jedi said, this is absolutely PIVOTAL to Anakin’s downfall, and the scene not being in the film lessens the whole idea of what he will do if he gets mad…BAD JEDI!! lol

I have thusly downloaded the Phantom Editor’s version, but the opening crawl killed that one for me, so I have settled for the Spence edit, which is very good.

JasonN… judging by your amazing work in Eps 1 and 3, if you put this scene and Anakin and Padme talking afterwords about the slaughter (yes, he’s whiny lol but the scene is very necessary), you would have likely made the perfect movie!!!

By: pokemonkey

pokemonkey — Thu, 13 Aug 2009 02:47:31 +0000

Good Edit…
Only thing i didn’t like is there is no Sand Storm kill after anakin gets mad. this is his path to the darkside.
Other then that the edit is awesome!

My favorite edit of the three is got to be the Phantom Menace edit by Jasonn (attack of the Federation) i think it’s the best Phantom menace edit i saw/

By: AbsolutFireman

AbsolutFireman — Mon, 25 May 2009 23:25:33 +0000

Amazing edits, all three of them are great. Keep it up.

By: p3jedi

p3jedi — Sun, 24 May 2009 02:05:45 +0000

8 / 10

A very impressive edit from start to finish. Technically brilliant, with no complaints on that front whatsoever. Now, having said that, my only quibbles involved retaining a little too much of Anakin’s “whining” and the decision to excise his mother’s death and his subsequent attack on the Sand People simply do not work. These events are pivotal to Anakin taking his first step toward the Dark Side, no matter how badly they were written.

By: searcher

searcher — Mon, 06 Apr 2009 15:07:57 +0000

This is the second edit I have watched of Attack of the clones, and this works very well, like what you did with the dooku light saber, no idea how you changed the colour? but it worked great. Wasn’t sure about removing the yoda fight, but never noticed any change at all. My wife didn’t like the yoda scene anyway, her description was a demented frog. This is a great alternative version of attack of the clones, and would highly recommend it. 9/10 for video and audio.