Comments on: Star Trek Pilots – Episode 2 – Deep Space Nine http://fanedit.org/7856/ The wonderful world of movies - edited by fans for fans Fri, 10 Feb 2012 21:31:25 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Uncanny Antman http://fanedit.org/7856/comment-page-1/#comment-11010 Uncanny Antman Sat, 12 Jun 2010 18:41:30 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=7856#comment-11010 I am an unabashed DS9 fan, so maybe my opinion on this one is a little biased. My opinion on this edit is mixed. There are very few technical problems with it, and those are from the original DVD transfer. (The DVDs range from average to atrocious.) The widescreen conversion is well handled with the exception of a small handful of shots. (And those are mostly just due to the shot being an extreme close-up on someone's face. Not much you can do to get around that.) The menus are just completely excellent. Some great use of the menu structure to mimic the LCARS interface. Very, very nice. So basically so far everything is either good, great, or flawed due to no fault of the editor. But I do have to give thumbs down to the removal of Ben Sisko's experience with The Prophets. I feel it negatively affects the episode on two levels. One, the continuity oddity that CBB mentions in the notes above. (ie: We have no information as to how Sisko got back to the runabout and out of the wormhole, or what happened between him and Gul Dukat in the Gamma Quadrant that led to him tractoring Dukat's ship back home.) The other reason is that now Sisko's emotional arc does not exist. There is no exploration as to why Sisko changes his mind and decides to stay on DS9. The removal of that plot strand aside, a recommended edit. Just don't let anyone watch it as their first experience with the series. ;) I am an unabashed DS9 fan, so maybe my opinion on this one is a little biased. My opinion on this edit is mixed. There are very few technical problems with it, and those are from the original DVD transfer. (The DVDs range from average to atrocious.)

The widescreen conversion is well handled with the exception of a small handful of shots. (And those are mostly just due to the shot being an extreme close-up on someone’s face. Not much you can do to get around that.)

The menus are just completely excellent. Some great use of the menu structure to mimic the LCARS interface. Very, very nice.

So basically so far everything is either good, great, or flawed due to no fault of the editor.

But I do have to give thumbs down to the removal of Ben Sisko’s experience with The Prophets. I feel it negatively affects the episode on two levels.

One, the continuity oddity that CBB mentions in the notes above. (ie: We have no information as to how Sisko got back to the runabout and out of the wormhole, or what happened between him and Gul Dukat in the Gamma Quadrant that led to him tractoring Dukat’s ship back home.)

The other reason is that now Sisko’s emotional arc does not exist. There is no exploration as to why Sisko changes his mind and decides to stay on DS9.

The removal of that plot strand aside, a recommended edit. Just don’t let anyone watch it as their first experience with the series. ;)

]]> By: ab5tract http://fanedit.org/7856/comment-page-1/#comment-10800 ab5tract Mon, 15 Feb 2010 16:13:11 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=7856#comment-10800 Excellent work here by CBB. The widescreen treatment has a huge effect on viewability for me, as a 4:3 production always feels like watching a TV show (unless its an old film shot in that aspect). The DS9 pilot is one of my favorites, so it was great to revisit it in this refreshing new way. In terms of continuity, there is only really even one audio switch (accompanying a commercial interlude, no doubt) that felt out of place. Other than that I found the editing to be flawless. I've given this a 10/10 because that's just how much better the viewing experience is in widescreen. (Didn't see any of these insurmountable issues mentioned by jjrdias myself). Excellent work here by CBB. The widescreen treatment has a huge effect on viewability for me, as a 4:3 production always feels like watching a TV show (unless its an old film shot in that aspect). The DS9 pilot is one of my favorites, so it was great to revisit it in this refreshing new way. In terms of continuity, there is only really even one audio switch (accompanying a commercial interlude, no doubt) that felt out of place. Other than that I found the editing to be flawless.

I’ve given this a 10/10 because that’s just how much better the viewing experience is in widescreen. (Didn’t see any of these insurmountable issues mentioned by jjrdias myself).

]]> By: jjrdias http://fanedit.org/7856/comment-page-1/#comment-10401 jjrdias Sun, 15 Nov 2009 15:05:59 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=7856#comment-10401 This "series" is a "must have" for any serious Star Trek buff, and the amount of work put into it should undoubtedly be praised. Loved the first episode, and this one is also really good and, technical constraints notwithstanding, both provide an awesome viewing experience - kinda like TMBM's SW "dusty" versions, but the other way around. Can't wait for the final instalment. PS: TNG had so many great two-episode specials that i'm sure at least some of them would also deserve this "treatment". 9/10 and only because cropping the image leads to some insurmountable issues. This “series” is a “must have” for any serious Star Trek buff, and the amount of work put into it should undoubtedly be praised. Loved the first episode, and this one is also really good and, technical constraints notwithstanding, both provide an awesome viewing experience – kinda like TMBM’s SW “dusty” versions, but the other way around. Can’t wait for the final instalment.

PS: TNG had so many great two-episode specials that i’m sure at least some of them would also deserve this “treatment”.

9/10 and only because cropping the image leads to some insurmountable issues.

]]>