Comments on: Attack Of The Clones Reviewed http://fanedit.org/9673/ The wonderful world of movies - edited by fans for fans Thu, 09 Feb 2012 21:32:36 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: mullholland665 http://fanedit.org/9673/comment-page-1/#comment-11084 mullholland665 Thu, 08 Jul 2010 11:15:43 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=9673#comment-11084 Like his Ep 1 review, I found this droll and insightful although not quite as funny. I think that's because uncovering the many faults in Attack Of The Clones is a more complicated affair, and thus Redlettermedia has spent more time on serious anaylsis. I dislike both prequels equally, but I always did find it harder to poinpoint the reasons why I found Attack Of The Clones such a failure. Nice work. Like his Ep 1 review, I found this droll and insightful although not quite as funny. I think that’s because uncovering the many faults in Attack Of The Clones is a more complicated affair, and thus Redlettermedia has spent more time on serious anaylsis. I dislike both prequels equally, but I always did find it harder to poinpoint the reasons why I found Attack Of The Clones such a failure. Nice work.

]]> By: Tmmchugh92 http://fanedit.org/9673/comment-page-1/#comment-10992 Tmmchugh92 Tue, 08 Jun 2010 04:18:01 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=9673#comment-10992 Epsidoe 2 may be one of my favorites not because of the love story but the relationship between obi wan and anakin and last 45 minutres of battle, but I like your review, it's really funny! Epsidoe 2 may be one of my favorites not because of the love story but the relationship between obi wan and anakin and last 45 minutres of battle, but I like your review, it’s really funny!

]]> By: jelio http://fanedit.org/9673/comment-page-1/#comment-10974 jelio Wed, 26 May 2010 16:42:36 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=9673#comment-10974 Very enjoyable and insightful, also a weird creepy subplot thats entertaining Very enjoyable and insightful, also a weird creepy subplot thats entertaining

]]> By: ab5tract http://fanedit.org/9673/comment-page-1/#comment-10954 ab5tract Thu, 06 May 2010 09:48:18 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=9673#comment-10954 Another one out of the park from Red Letter Media! If you have watched and enjoyed either of the other Reviews (Star Trek, The Phantom Menace) do not hesitate to download this right away. Lots of great criticism. I honestly believe the reason I like these so much is that "misery loves company." It is nice to watch Attack of the Clones with someone who hates it as much as I do. "It's not just a movie.. It's the biggest disappointment in cinematic history." Contrary to flyboy and zeppelinrox, I felt that the serial killer moments in this review added a lot of characterization to the fictional narrator. The woman is a good actor as well, delivering some great lines. "what the **** is going on? who the **** are these people?" This is in contrast to the Phantom Menace review, in which the basement scenes just made me really uncomfortable. They felt out of place. It's obvious now that Red Letter Media has a narrative arc planned across his trilogy of reviews. If the basement scenes in the first one bothered you, check this one out. For me the characterization really changed my opinion of what he is doing with that. It is still pretty edgy, and could easily offend some, but the FE community knows me as pretty sensitive on these issues. I'm not saying its for everyone, and its still sort of random in the first place, but this installment actually gives the serial killer element a reason for existing. And, now, our characters are at their lowest point. As they should be, in a trilogy. Personally, I'm hoping the woman and the narrator admit their undying love for each other in Revenge of the Sith Reviewed. Another one out of the park from Red Letter Media! If you have watched and enjoyed either of the other Reviews (Star Trek, The Phantom Menace) do not hesitate to download this right away. Lots of great criticism. I honestly believe the reason I like these so much is that “misery loves company.” It is nice to watch Attack of the Clones with someone who hates it as much as I do.

“It’s not just a movie.. It’s the biggest disappointment in cinematic history.”

Contrary to flyboy and zeppelinrox, I felt that the serial killer moments in this review added a lot of characterization to the fictional narrator. The woman is a good actor as well, delivering some great lines. “what the **** is going on? who the **** are these people?”

This is in contrast to the Phantom Menace review, in which the basement scenes just made me really uncomfortable. They felt out of place. It’s obvious now that Red Letter Media has a narrative arc planned across his trilogy of reviews. If the basement scenes in the first one bothered you, check this one out. For me the characterization really changed my opinion of what he is doing with that. It is still pretty edgy, and could easily offend some, but the FE community knows me as pretty sensitive on these issues. I’m not saying its for everyone, and its still sort of random in the first place, but this installment actually gives the serial killer element a reason for existing.

And, now, our characters are at their lowest point. As they should be, in a trilogy. Personally, I’m hoping the woman and the narrator admit their undying love for each other in Revenge of the Sith Reviewed.

]]> By: zeppelinrox http://fanedit.org/9673/comment-page-1/#comment-10880 zeppelinrox Thu, 08 Apr 2010 23:09:44 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=9673#comment-10880 I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. Sure, The Phantom Menace review one was fantastic but you know what they say about a one trick pony. So I really didn't have my hopes set very high. I'm happy to say that it is as enjoyable as the first one with a few real LOL moments that had me grinning. This is better than most comedies that you'd find playing at theatres these days. There are a few funny moments with the girls making fun of the reviewer but yeah, some of the serial killer stuff is wearing thin. Hopefully, he gets "killed", in a very hilarious way, at the end of Part III's review. I enjoyed this more than I thought I would.
Sure, The Phantom Menace review one was fantastic but you know what they say about a one trick pony.
So I really didn’t have my hopes set very high.

I’m happy to say that it is as enjoyable as the first one with a few real LOL moments that had me grinning.

This is better than most comedies that you’d find playing at theatres these days.

There are a few funny moments with the girls making fun of the reviewer but yeah, some of the serial killer stuff is wearing thin.

Hopefully, he gets “killed”, in a very hilarious way, at the end of Part III’s review.

]]> By: flyboy707 http://fanedit.org/9673/comment-page-1/#comment-10879 flyboy707 Thu, 08 Apr 2010 22:23:54 +0000 http://fanedit.org/?p=9673#comment-10879 I am a fan of these. There is as much humor, as there is true criticism. I will have to say, I like "The Phantom Menace" review the most out of all three of these (there is a Star Trek Next Gen movies review as well). The first one offers the most comment of true, insightful cinematic criticism than this one does. Although, he is still spot on as to why "Attack of the Clones" is a bad movie. The only thing I disliked about this one is : too much of the "serial killer", "I have women locked in my basement" scenes going on. I am no prude and have no issues with this content, I just don't find these portions that funny in this review. Boon23's comments about why bothering to D/L this is spot on. I have all three versions in the "dvd" format and much prefer it to watching the youtube clips. On the whole, if you liked the other review redlettermedia has produced, then this is for you too. I am a fan of these. There is as much humor, as there is true criticism.

I will have to say, I like “The Phantom Menace” review the most out of all three of these (there is a Star Trek Next Gen movies review as well). The first one offers the most comment of true, insightful cinematic criticism than this one does. Although, he is still spot on as to why “Attack of the Clones” is a bad movie.

The only thing I disliked about this one is : too much of the “serial killer”, “I have women locked in my basement” scenes going on. I am no prude and have no issues with this content, I just don’t find these portions that funny in this review.

Boon23’s comments about why bothering to D/L this is spot on. I have all three versions in the “dvd” format and much prefer it to watching the youtube clips.

On the whole, if you liked the other review redlettermedia has produced, then this is for you too.

]]>