In The Spotlight – Horror Fanedits

One of the major sections for fanedits are horror movies. And there is a good reason for that. It is one of the most fascinatingmovie genres, where hardly any movie was created as a huge blockbuster, but rather as B movie, often not featuring any of the grand names of film business.
People love to be scared, it’s a solo sensation as well as a team or even mating event. The scary ones have a major impact, which can result in being frightened, having nightmares, being truly affected by the fearful things happening on the screen. Yet causing fear is a very difficult business, especially when an audience is used to this genre. And this is where so manyhorror movies often fail. A movie like PARANORMAL ACTIVITY proved to us that it does not require huge amounts of gore or blood to scare people. It depends on the plot, on the presentation and very much on the pacing. Scares are a rather primitive emotion and many directors tend to over-complicate things in their movies.
That’s when the faneditors enter to correct what usually was too much, did not work or just begged for deletion.
In the history of fanedits horror movies play an important part. They recieve a lot of downloads and major attention. The reasonfor that is that so many people were disappointed by horror movies, but also able to catch a glimpse of what could have actually been interesting to watch. Horror movies are often perfect candidates to watch for a second time in a different version.
A history of horror fanedits:
Two of the first truly successful horror fanedits were based on the movie HANNIBAL by Ridley Scott. The original suffered fromlong and boring scenes, bad pacing and not enough “SILENCE OF THE LAMBS”. It was a very successful movie though, because of the great character of Hannibal Lecter. The 2 fanedits were an extended edition and a true fanedit, namely Hannibal: Desserts Served With Your Main Course by ADigitalMan and Hannibal – Special Hannibalized Edition by CBB. Both of them included various of the deleted scenes, but only Hannibalized cut scenes from the original movie. MAIN COURSE was praised for its deeper characters and Hannibalized for an overall way more interesting plot. People wanted an improved version and the faneditors delivered, where the studios did not and let the audience endure, what they had created, as if a movie was something solid. Well, since the Star Wars Special Editions we all know, this is not true. There can be so many versions of a movie and each of them can attract a very different audience for very different reasons.That’s the great thing about fanedits. As for the Hannibal fanedits both of them had one importnat thing in common: they both used the alternate ending, where Hannibal does not chop off his own hand. And the entire audience agrees that this ending is indeed the more bleievable and better one.
And this brings us to another very interesting and also a bit genre specific theme: freshness.
Now why did Ridley Scott use the ending he used? Why do directors and studios make the decisions they make, even if they can besometimes so obviously wrong? Blindness is the answer. Not being able to see a movie anymore from a fresh perspective. It takes months to create a movie, the same scenes are watched over and over again, which steals any kind of impact they had in the first place. So in the end the ones in charge are not really able anymore to decide what is working, what is good and what is not.
Mr.Scott probably thought something was missing in the alternate ending and he is nto wrong there, because the alternate scene is indeed a bit flat, yet the alternative he chose makes thigns worse not better, by letting the lead actor do something he was not likely to.
The faneditors main advantage is to see the final version from a fresh perspective and judge just that, but also withthe incredible option and possibility to change that.
The next horror movie to cause attention as a fanedit was Dawn of the dead. The fanedit was named: Dawn Of The Dead: The Extended Mall Hours Cut by OfficiallyUnofficial and was an ultimate version created from all 3 available vesions of the original, featuring about ANY scene available. This time the audience wanted the super-extended version of a cult movie and the faneditors were the ones to create and deliver it.
Army of Darkness — Primitive Screwhead Edition by Ridgeshark went into the very same direction, but also left it to the audience to decide themselves through seamless branching, which version with which alternate scenes they wanted to watch. AOD won for good reason and with no real competition the prize for best extended edition in 2008 on Fanedit.org.
Hellblazer remixed by Jorge was a daring take on what many consider not even a horror movie: the mess CONSTANTINE. The original disappointed both fans of the graphic novels and horror film fans. With his smart editing, Jorge took care of this movie and turned it into an enjoyable horror ride. And the audience applauded and loved it.
These few example from the almost old times of fanedits (yes, we are still abrand new genre) show what the desires of theaudience are. Less and More. If it’s a cult movie they want more. And if it’s a flawed one they want less, but with much more impact.
The audience (and faneditors come directly from that audience) is the one to endure the movie, to live through them. And it seemsthat for such a genre like horror they have a better knowledge of what works in many cases than the directors, producers, studios, who tend to release superficial and lame horror crap, but with enough scenes in it for the fans to step in and improve on it.
| Here is a list of the 10 most successful horror fanedits of all time: | ||||||
![]() |
The Terminator – Extended Edition |
|||||
![]() |
Blade 3 – Behead The King Edition |
|||||
![]() |
Dawn Of The Dead: The Extended Mall Hours Cut |
|||||
![]() |
Army Of Darkness: Prmitive Screwhead Edition |
|||||
![]() |
Romero’s Land Of The Dead: Unrated FanCut |
|||||
![]() |
Doom – The Posessed Re-Cut |
|||||
![]() |
Event Horizon: Slashed aka Killer Horizon EVENT HORIZON left a lot to be desired, yet it had such great moments that it even though being an overall bad movie gained a fanbase and cult status. |
|||||
![]() |
Azazel |
|||||
![]() |
Dead Set Serious |
|||||
![]() |
JAWS The Sharksploitation Edit by TMBTM With the new and unique idea to NOT EVEN TRY to improve on a masterpiece like JAWS, but turn it into an all surprising cheap 70s horror flick, TMBTM gatecrashed into the world of movies and earned nothing but respect and applause for his masterful and truly funny take on one of the best movies ever created. Of course it got the best true fanedit of the month award on Fanedit.org, thousands of downloads and attention everywhere. One of the most outstanding fanedit projects ever created. >>>>MORE |
|||||












