Top 25 edits
- 1. Star Wars: Ep IV Special Edition Revisited
- 2. Terminator 3: The Coming Storm
- 3. Star Wars Episode 2: Attack Of The Phantom
- 4. Army Of Darkness – Primitive Screwhead Edition
- 4. Dawn of the Dead: The “Extended Mall Hours” Cut
- 6. Jaws the Sharksploitation Edit
- 7. Batman Consecution: The True Fanedit Chronicles
- 8. Romero’s Land Of The Dead: Unrated Fancut
- 9. Building Empire
- 10. The Dark Knight: Remixed by Jorge
- 11. The Terminator: Extended Edition
- 12. Returning to Jedi
- 13. Star Wars Episode 1: The Phantom Edit
- 14. The Descent – Scary as Hell Edition
- 15. Halloween 2K7 – Scary as Hell Edition
- 16. Hellblazer: remixed by Jorge
- 17. Star Wars: Deleted Magic Revisited
- 18. Blade Runner: 2008 Extended Edition
- 19. The Crow: city of angels – Second Coming
- 20. Batman Begins: Dark Cut
- 21. Sin City – Recut Extended Unrated Theatrical Cut
- 22. The Story of the Empire Strikes Back
- 23. Pearl Harbor: Strength and Honor Edition
- 24. Superman Redeemed
- 25. Transformers: (UA Edit)
I try to update this list once a month, but it might happen that it takes longer. If you can’t wait the results are almost always up on time in the forums! The list uses 10 dummy votes set to the database average rating to decide the ranking.
Last update 20100303 (data pulled on 100226)
Climbers:
Halloween 2K7 – Scary as Hell Edition +10
The Terminator: Extended Edition +6
The Dark Knight: Remixed by Jorge +5
Star Wars Episode 1: The Phantom Edit +5
Building Empire +4
Returning to Jedi +4
Romero’s Land Of The Dead: Unrated Fancut +3
Batman Consecution: The True Fanedit Chronicles +2
Hellblazer: remixed by Jorge +2
Dawn of the Dead: The “Extended Mall Hours” Cut +1
Jaws the Sharksploitation Edit +1
Most of this is of course due to all the cbb edits being removed from competition, and the side effect of their removal that the average rating dropped significantly.
Top Ten changes:
Gone is Dead Set Serious, Star Trek:Kirkless Generations and Prison Break – The Movie – Episode 1, all cbb edits that had made it into the top 10. We will of course remember their greatness. New are two old ones, Land of the Dead and Building Empire, along with a new top 10 entry, The Dark Knight. And that’s a well deserved recognition for one of the best edits of 2009. The eternal contest of fourth place is a draw this month.
New Fanedits on the list:
14. The Descent – Scary as Hell Edition
17. Star Wars: Deleted Magic Revisited
18. Blade Runner: 2008 Extended Edition
19. The Crow: city of angels – Second Coming
20. Batman Begins: Dark Cut
21. Sin City – Recut Extended Unrated Theatrical Cut
22. The Story of the Empire Strikes Back
23. Pearl Harbor: Strength and Honor Edition
24. Superman Redeemed
25. Transformers: (UA Edit)
An entire new squadron of edits rush in to fill the empty spots. New ones to the top 25 include the dark cut of Batman Begins, Pearl Harbour and Transformers, and most notably The Descent.
Fanedits off the list:
Dead Set Serious
Star Trek – Kirkless Generations
Prison Break – The Movie – Episode One
Braveheart: Elerslie Edition
Doom The Posessed Re-Cut
Red Dragon – Manhunter Edition
Azazel
Flatliners – True Nightmare Edition
Two Exits from Pan’s Labyrinth
Blade 3 – Behead The King Edition
How crazy is this? 10 edits among the top 25 best rated shows the continued great work that Boon has put out over the years.
Hottest contender for making it onto the list:
The list is very different now, but a good candidate could be The Nightmare On Elm Street Anthology, Volume 1. Truly outstanding ratings so far, and still a fairly new release.
Votes increase:
16. Not that good this month either.



