Review Detail
9.8 23 10
Extended Edition
December 11, 2017
12509
Overall rating
9.8
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
9.0
Enjoyment
10.0
This is the go-to version of Cap's Winter Soldier adventure. Video editing is seamless for transitions and quality matching (on a 106" projection). Audio editing is seamless (on a 2.1 channel system). All additions are worthwhile.
The green-screen is finished so well I didn't notice it when I watched the movie. Afterwards when I specifically went back to that scene to look for it, I recognized edges during a few moving shots. Very impressive editing!
The only debatable point is whether the movie would be better if some scenes are trimmed. For my preference Barnes gets too much screen time, but I do think that the pacing of the movie is great as it is. So I'm not sure if trimming any Barnes would work well for the risk of throwing off the overall pacing.
The green-screen is finished so well I didn't notice it when I watched the movie. Afterwards when I specifically went back to that scene to look for it, I recognized edges during a few moving shots. Very impressive editing!
The only debatable point is whether the movie would be better if some scenes are trimmed. For my preference Barnes gets too much screen time, but I do think that the pacing of the movie is great as it is. So I'm not sure if trimming any Barnes would work well for the risk of throwing off the overall pacing.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched
Digital
