Lord of the Rings, The: The Two Towers: Sharkey’s Purist Edition

Updated
 
9.1 (3)
5287 1 4
Lord of the Rings, The: The Two Towers: Sharkey’s Purist Edition
Faneditor Name:
Original Movie/Show Title:
Genre:
Fanedit Type:
Original Release Date:
2002
Original Running Time:
223 minutes
Fanedit Release Date:
Fanedit Running Time:
173 minutes
Time Cut:
76 minutes
Time Added:
26 minutes
Synopsis:
Modeled after the “purist edition” of TTT that has floated around for the past few years, this fan edit sets out to bring the Jackson films more in line with Tolkien’s original novel. Hopefully a version the die-hard Tolkien purists can find easier to stomach, by removing as many offending bits as possible.
Intention:
Modeled after the “purist edition” of TTT that has floated around for the past few years, this fan edit sets out to bring the Jackson films more in line with Tolkien’s original novel. Hopefully a version the die-hard Tolkien purists can find easier to stomach, by removing as many offending bits as possible.
Editing Details:
Aside from small cuts, such things have been cut away as: Saruman is not Sauron’s direct subservient, Arwen is not sailing to Valinor, Theoden is not a coward and does not hold a groundless grudge against Gondor, Faramir does not drag the hobbits to Osgiliath, Frodo does not attempt to give the ring to a Nazgul, no elves at the Hornburg, the Ents do not refuse to attack Isengard, and the good guys already know Sauron moves against Minas Tirith.
Cuts and Additions:


Cut the eye of Sauron’s interaction with Frodo at the beginning. Downplayed Sauron’s floating eye as much as possible.
Trimmed Gimli’s comedic relief during their pursuit of Merry and Pippin.
Cut Frodo’s acid trip in the waters of the Dead Marshes.
Inserted Smeagol’s backstory, formerly the prologue to the third film, into his conversation with Frodo during their nighttime scene in the Dead Marshes.
Cut Gimli’s remark about squirrel droppings.
Treebeard discovers Saruman’s ravashing of the woods prior to scheduling the Entmoot. Treebeard is trying to convince the other Ents to go to war.
Gandalf does not refer to Saruman as “Sauron’s puppet.” We do not see or hear from Saruman directly until after Helm’s Deep.
Cut the peril at the Blake Gate, with Sam getting stuck in the ground and nearly spotted.
Cut most of the backstory of Rohan, primarilly to sever the concept that Saruman is working for Sauron directly. We are introduced to Rohan via the eyes of Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli, which is more like the book.
Removed the children arriving on horseback, since the burning of the Westfold was removed.
Removed the antagonism between Theoden and Aragorn, and Gondor.
Theoden’s decision to move to Helm’s Deep is equated with riding out to meet Saruman in battle, and Gandalf does not view it as a cowardly decision of retreat.
Saruman and Wormtongue’s scenes at Orthanc are cut.
Cut Frodo’s outburst toward Sam regarding Gollum along the river.
Cut the warg attack along with Aragorn’s separation from the rest of the van and his rescue by Brego the wonderhorse, who’s earlier introduction was also cut.
Aragorn and Arwen’s “dream” scene is retained, along with a modified version of her scene with Elrond. She is not sailing to Valinor, and has already made up her mind. (The prophetic description of Elrond about the end of her life matches the book’s appendices.)
Faramir is made to appear less Boromir-like and mistreatful to the hobbits. As he is in the book, a gentle and insightful Captain of Gondor.
Cut Boromir and Faramir’s backstory. Denethor did not send Boromir to the Council of Elrond for the express purpose of bringing the One Ring back to him. It ruins all justification of Boromir as a member of the Fellowship, making him an undercover agent who was not sincere in his pledge to it. He came to Rivendell because of his vision, and was corrupted more gradually toward the Ring.
Removed Theoden’s antagonism toward Gondor prior to the battle.
There are no elves, save Legolas, at the battle of the Hornburg. The movie’s depiction is comparable to an army from Canada inexplicably arriving to bolster the Polish defenses during WWII. In Tolkien’s Middle-Earth, this is baffling.
The Entmoot makes the correct decision the first time, to attack Isengard, and do so. Merry and Pippin are not sent home to the Shire.
Trimmed the drawf-tossing reference.
Faramir does not decide to take the Ring to Gondor, and does not take Sam and Frodo to Osgiliath. He meditates on the death of his brother, and then releases them into the woods of Ithilien.
Cut Gimli’s line about an orc’s nervous system, because it is too modern of a term and seems jarring.
About 27 minutes from the third film have been bumped up here, to finish off the falling action surrounding Helm’s Deep and Edoras, and allowing the third film to begin with Minas Tirith. Also prevents a ghastly discrepancy between the films’ running times.
Fixed a continuity error in the extended editions where Merry and Pippin identify the Longbottom Leaf (in what formerly was their introduction in the third film) after being shown already knowing what it is (in a scene added to the extended edition of the second film). They weren’t *that* stoned.
Cut the sub-plot about not knowing where Sauron would strike next.
Removed Gimli’s and Legolas’s drinking game. (Here’s a drinking game: take a swig every time Jackson deviates from Tolkien’s writings.)
Pippin does not discover Sauron’s next move via the Palantir.
Removed more of Theoden’s antagonism toward Gondor at Gandalf’s briefing scene.
Pippin rides with Gandalf toward Minas Tirith, we cut back to Frodo and Sam and go to credits.
Faneditor Name:
Original Movie/Show Title:
Genre:
Fanedit Type:
Original Release Date:
2002
Original Running Time:
223 minutes
Fanedit Release Date:
Fanedit Running Time:
173 minutes
Time Cut:
76 minutes
Time Added:
26 minutes
Synopsis:
Modeled after the “purist edition” of TTT that has floated around for the past few years, this fan edit sets out to bring the Jackson films more in line with Tolkien’s original novel. Hopefully a version the die-hard Tolkien purists can find easier to stomach, by removing as many offending bits as possible.
Intention:
Modeled after the “purist edition” of TTT that has floated around for the past few years, this fan edit sets out to bring the Jackson films more in line with Tolkien’s original novel. Hopefully a version the die-hard Tolkien purists can find easier to stomach, by removing as many offending bits as possible.
Editing Details:
Aside from small cuts, such things have been cut away as: Saruman is not Sauron’s direct subservient, Arwen is not sailing to Valinor, Theoden is not a coward and does not hold a groundless grudge against Gondor, Faramir does not drag the hobbits to Osgiliath, Frodo does not attempt to give the ring to a Nazgul, no elves at the Hornburg, the Ents do not refuse to attack Isengard, and the good guys already know Sauron moves against Minas Tirith.
Cuts and Additions:


Cut the eye of Sauron’s interaction with Frodo at the beginning. Downplayed Sauron’s floating eye as much as possible.
Trimmed Gimli’s comedic relief during their pursuit of Merry and Pippin.
Cut Frodo’s acid trip in the waters of the Dead Marshes.
Inserted Smeagol’s backstory, formerly the prologue to the third film, into his conversation with Frodo during their nighttime scene in the Dead Marshes.
Cut Gimli’s remark about squirrel droppings.
Treebeard discovers Saruman’s ravashing of the woods prior to scheduling the Entmoot. Treebeard is trying to convince the other Ents to go to war.
Gandalf does not refer to Saruman as “Sauron’s puppet.” We do not see or hear from Saruman directly until after Helm’s Deep.
Cut the peril at the Blake Gate, with Sam getting stuck in the ground and nearly spotted.
Cut most of the backstory of Rohan, primarilly to sever the concept that Saruman is working for Sauron directly. We are introduced to Rohan via the eyes of Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli, which is more like the book.
Removed the children arriving on horseback, since the burning of the Westfold was removed.
Removed the antagonism between Theoden and Aragorn, and Gondor.
Theoden’s decision to move to Helm’s Deep is equated with riding out to meet Saruman in battle, and Gandalf does not view it as a cowardly decision of retreat.
Saruman and Wormtongue’s scenes at Orthanc are cut.
Cut Frodo’s outburst toward Sam regarding Gollum along the river.
Cut the warg attack along with Aragorn’s separation from the rest of the van and his rescue by Brego the wonderhorse, who’s earlier introduction was also cut.
Aragorn and Arwen’s “dream” scene is retained, along with a modified version of her scene with Elrond. She is not sailing to Valinor, and has already made up her mind. (The prophetic description of Elrond about the end of her life matches the book’s appendices.)
Faramir is made to appear less Boromir-like and mistreatful to the hobbits. As he is in the book, a gentle and insightful Captain of Gondor.
Cut Boromir and Faramir’s backstory. Denethor did not send Boromir to the Council of Elrond for the express purpose of bringing the One Ring back to him. It ruins all justification of Boromir as a member of the Fellowship, making him an undercover agent who was not sincere in his pledge to it. He came to Rivendell because of his vision, and was corrupted more gradually toward the Ring.
Removed Theoden’s antagonism toward Gondor prior to the battle.
There are no elves, save Legolas, at the battle of the Hornburg. The movie’s depiction is comparable to an army from Canada inexplicably arriving to bolster the Polish defenses during WWII. In Tolkien’s Middle-Earth, this is baffling.
The Entmoot makes the correct decision the first time, to attack Isengard, and do so. Merry and Pippin are not sent home to the Shire.
Trimmed the drawf-tossing reference.
Faramir does not decide to take the Ring to Gondor, and does not take Sam and Frodo to Osgiliath. He meditates on the death of his brother, and then releases them into the woods of Ithilien.
Cut Gimli’s line about an orc’s nervous system, because it is too modern of a term and seems jarring.
About 27 minutes from the third film have been bumped up here, to finish off the falling action surrounding Helm’s Deep and Edoras, and allowing the third film to begin with Minas Tirith. Also prevents a ghastly discrepancy between the films’ running times.
Fixed a continuity error in the extended editions where Merry and Pippin identify the Longbottom Leaf (in what formerly was their introduction in the third film) after being shown already knowing what it is (in a scene added to the extended edition of the second film). They weren’t *that* stoned.
Cut the sub-plot about not knowing where Sauron would strike next.
Removed Gimli’s and Legolas’s drinking game. (Here’s a drinking game: take a swig every time Jackson deviates from Tolkien’s writings.)
Pippin does not discover Sauron’s next move via the Palantir.
Removed more of Theoden’s antagonism toward Gondor at Gandalf’s briefing scene.
Pippin rides with Gandalf toward Minas Tirith, we cut back to Frodo and Sam and go to credits.
Cover art by boon23 (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Cover art by AvP (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Cover art by boon23 (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Cover art by Ghostcut (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Cover art by Throwgncpr (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Faneditor Name:
Original Movie/Show Title:
Genre:
Fanedit Type:
Original Release Date:
2002
Original Running Time:
223 minutes
Fanedit Release Date:
Fanedit Running Time:
173 minutes
Time Cut:
76 minutes
Time Added:
26 minutes
Synopsis:
Modeled after the “purist edition” of TTT that has floated around for the past few years, this fan edit sets out to bring the Jackson films more in line with Tolkien’s original novel. Hopefully a version the die-hard Tolkien purists can find easier to stomach, by removing as many offending bits as possible.
Intention:
Modeled after the “purist edition” of TTT that has floated around for the past few years, this fan edit sets out to bring the Jackson films more in line with Tolkien’s original novel. Hopefully a version the die-hard Tolkien purists can find easier to stomach, by removing as many offending bits as possible.
Editing Details:
Aside from small cuts, such things have been cut away as: Saruman is not Sauron’s direct subservient, Arwen is not sailing to Valinor, Theoden is not a coward and does not hold a groundless grudge against Gondor, Faramir does not drag the hobbits to Osgiliath, Frodo does not attempt to give the ring to a Nazgul, no elves at the Hornburg, the Ents do not refuse to attack Isengard, and the good guys already know Sauron moves against Minas Tirith.
Cuts and Additions:


Cut the eye of Sauron’s interaction with Frodo at the beginning. Downplayed Sauron’s floating eye as much as possible.
Trimmed Gimli’s comedic relief during their pursuit of Merry and Pippin.
Cut Frodo’s acid trip in the waters of the Dead Marshes.
Inserted Smeagol’s backstory, formerly the prologue to the third film, into his conversation with Frodo during their nighttime scene in the Dead Marshes.
Cut Gimli’s remark about squirrel droppings.
Treebeard discovers Saruman’s ravashing of the woods prior to scheduling the Entmoot. Treebeard is trying to convince the other Ents to go to war.
Gandalf does not refer to Saruman as “Sauron’s puppet.” We do not see or hear from Saruman directly until after Helm’s Deep.
Cut the peril at the Blake Gate, with Sam getting stuck in the ground and nearly spotted.
Cut most of the backstory of Rohan, primarilly to sever the concept that Saruman is working for Sauron directly. We are introduced to Rohan via the eyes of Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli, which is more like the book.
Removed the children arriving on horseback, since the burning of the Westfold was removed.
Removed the antagonism between Theoden and Aragorn, and Gondor.
Theoden’s decision to move to Helm’s Deep is equated with riding out to meet Saruman in battle, and Gandalf does not view it as a cowardly decision of retreat.
Saruman and Wormtongue’s scenes at Orthanc are cut.
Cut Frodo’s outburst toward Sam regarding Gollum along the river.
Cut the warg attack along with Aragorn’s separation from the rest of the van and his rescue by Brego the wonderhorse, who’s earlier introduction was also cut.
Aragorn and Arwen’s “dream” scene is retained, along with a modified version of her scene with Elrond. She is not sailing to Valinor, and has already made up her mind. (The prophetic description of Elrond about the end of her life matches the book’s appendices.)
Faramir is made to appear less Boromir-like and mistreatful to the hobbits. As he is in the book, a gentle and insightful Captain of Gondor.
Cut Boromir and Faramir’s backstory. Denethor did not send Boromir to the Council of Elrond for the express purpose of bringing the One Ring back to him. It ruins all justification of Boromir as a member of the Fellowship, making him an undercover agent who was not sincere in his pledge to it. He came to Rivendell because of his vision, and was corrupted more gradually toward the Ring.
Removed Theoden’s antagonism toward Gondor prior to the battle.
There are no elves, save Legolas, at the battle of the Hornburg. The movie’s depiction is comparable to an army from Canada inexplicably arriving to bolster the Polish defenses during WWII. In Tolkien’s Middle-Earth, this is baffling.
The Entmoot makes the correct decision the first time, to attack Isengard, and do so. Merry and Pippin are not sent home to the Shire.
Trimmed the drawf-tossing reference.
Faramir does not decide to take the Ring to Gondor, and does not take Sam and Frodo to Osgiliath. He meditates on the death of his brother, and then releases them into the woods of Ithilien.
Cut Gimli’s line about an orc’s nervous system, because it is too modern of a term and seems jarring.
About 27 minutes from the third film have been bumped up here, to finish off the falling action surrounding Helm’s Deep and Edoras, and allowing the third film to begin with Minas Tirith. Also prevents a ghastly discrepancy between the films’ running times.
Fixed a continuity error in the extended editions where Merry and Pippin identify the Longbottom Leaf (in what formerly was their introduction in the third film) after being shown already knowing what it is (in a scene added to the extended edition of the second film). They weren’t *that* stoned.
Cut the sub-plot about not knowing where Sauron would strike next.
Removed Gimli’s and Legolas’s drinking game. (Here’s a drinking game: take a swig every time Jackson deviates from Tolkien’s writings.)
Pippin does not discover Sauron’s next move via the Palantir.
Removed more of Theoden’s antagonism toward Gondor at Gandalf’s briefing scene.
Pippin rides with Gandalf toward Minas Tirith, we cut back to Frodo and Sam and go to credits.
Cover art by boon23 (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Cover art by AvP (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Cover art by boon23 (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Cover art by Ghostcut (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

Cover art by Throwgncpr (DOWNLOAD HERE)
image

User reviews

3 reviews
Overall rating
 
9.1
Audio/Video Quality
 
8.5(2)
Audio Editing
 
10.0(2)
Visual Editing
 
10.0(2)
Narrative
 
8.0(2)
Enjoyment
 
8.3(3)
Overall rating
 
8.2
Audio/Video Quality
 
7.0
Audio Editing
 
10.0
Visual Editing
 
10.0
Narrative
 
6.0
Enjoyment
 
8.0
Reducing the number of times we see Sauron's floating eye is a good idea.
Also, Gimli is improved, we don’t need all the jokes being about him.

The highlight of the edit is the inclusion of the Smeagol backstory, cut from the third film. It’s a great place for it, and it helps to reduce the runtime of Return of the King.

Cutting Aragorn's separation implied cutting the warg attack, and that was a mistake in my opinion. Too much of the story is lost.

The main issue here was the stated objective of removing all the elves from the Hornburg. I get the intention, but during the entire battle I can see dozens of elves, they are so many there’s no way of cutting them without removing the entire battle. This creates dozens of continuity errors, where I see elves all the time fighting, with no explanation of how they got there in the first place.
The intention was to fix a (slight to moderate) mistake, the solution created dozens of continuity errors, it just does not work.

My other gripe is the visual quality, the lower resolution and low bit rate are really noticeable in some sections.

User Review

Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
Report this review Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0
Overall rating
 
10.0
Audio/Video Quality
 
10.0
Audio Editing
 
10.0
Visual Editing
 
10.0
Narrative
 
10.0
Enjoyment
 
9.0
Another technically well done and seamless edit, and the additional footage from RotK was most welcome. The removal of anachronistic elves at Helm's Deep and all the other deviations were perfect. I do miss Theoden's "exorcism" from the original, as well as the action sequence from Osgiliath, even though the latter was wholly inaccurate to the book.

Overall, a highly recommended edit.

User Review

Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
B
Report this review Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0
(Updated: September 17, 2012)
Overall rating
 
8.0
Audio/Video Quality
 
N/A
Audio Editing
 
N/A
Visual Editing
 
N/A
Narrative
 
N/A
Enjoyment
 
8.0
Review by xGrind - February 14, 2010 @ 10:30 am

*This rating was given before reviews were required*
Report this review Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0