Review Detail
9.8 60 10Overall rating
9.5
Audio/Video Quality
9.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
9.0
Enjoyment
9.0
Absolutely fantastic edit, it actually made the movies watchable for me.
I stopped watching the Hobbit trilogy when I was about half way through the second movie when it came out and never looked back,
aside from some Youtube videos (which confirmed my decision to stop watching these films) I haven't really wanted to go back and watch these movies as they were and this shakeup was really what I needed to give them another chance.
The CGI is still bad, greenscreen is abundant and distracting, the fight scenes are sub-par, and despite all of that this cut makes the painful bits less outstanding (and cuts as much of the bs as possible) which at-least makes these movies (now one movie) watchable and mostly enjoyable.
Thanks M4
I stopped watching the Hobbit trilogy when I was about half way through the second movie when it came out and never looked back,
aside from some Youtube videos (which confirmed my decision to stop watching these films) I haven't really wanted to go back and watch these movies as they were and this shakeup was really what I needed to give them another chance.
The CGI is still bad, greenscreen is abundant and distracting, the fight scenes are sub-par, and despite all of that this cut makes the painful bits less outstanding (and cuts as much of the bs as possible) which at-least makes these movies (now one movie) watchable and mostly enjoyable.
Thanks M4
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched
Blu-ray