Reviewed by mariondomenei
"Wow this edit is 100% so much more enjoyable than the theatrical cut, which for me is only 6 or 7 out of 10. The film is just okay - not bad, not great. However, this edit makes so much improvement for the overall narrative, pacing, and enjoyment. This is..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"Overall, the episodic format is highly, if not equally, enjoyable to watch compared to movie format. It is a must watch among other fanedits. The trims and cuts adds focus on the films' overall narrative, which is a very welcome choice. There really is nothing to say on technical side..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"This edit is superbly done no doubt about that. I really love the reinserted deleted scenes and cuts here and there. Although I must say that I am conflicted as to which one I like most, the original vs the alternate ending. The ending really has a more lasting impact..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"This is a light edit, but superbly done. The "To-Do List" is of course the most essential reintegration (adding more to the overall story or at least Peter's character development), while the other two are subtle yet still a welcome addition. I would highly recommend this to anyone even for..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"The editing is perfect! The added scenes where great and adds to the overall character development I think. I remember seeing bits of the "to do list" deleted scene from the trailers and I kinda missed it on the theatrical cut. The other two added scenes where subtle but..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"Perfect! I love all of the added scenes, how it was inserted, the editing is top notch. If I didn't know about the deleted scenes, I wouldn't recognize them. I'm a sucker for extended editions of films that I already love. Definitely will recommend to anyone, like me, who are..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"I good finale for the Sherlock fan edits! Overall I truly enjoyed the film. But one thing I didn't like is how it ended after the line "it is what it is". I felt that it ended abruptly, but maybe it's just me. "
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"I have somewhat mixed feelings about this edit. Pros: Overall feel of the film was definitely different than the rest of the show, even comparing to "The Fall" and "The Return" fan edits (still haven't watched "The Lies" by Zarius). And I kinda dig it, in a way. The..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"Watched this a day after watching "The Fall of Sherlock". Story-wise, "The Fall" have more impact to the viewers as the story between Sherlock and Moriarty has intensity (its like a "climax arc" of some sort), whereas in this edit, "The Return", I think it's a little bit of a..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"I enjoyed watching this edit from start to finish. Highly recommendable for every Sherlock fans. What this edit achieved was to highlight the intensity of the rivalry between Sherlock and Moriarty, in a way that is much better than what was presented originally as an episodic structure. Especially considering 2..."
Reviewed by mariondomenei
"I love this edit so much. The way that Wraith had combined the original trilogy was great. The story now focuses on both Jean Grey and Logan (but mostly on Jean, actually), and although minor characters have taken a back seat in this edit (like Rogue, Kitty, etc.), it does..."