Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"I decided I should hurry up and watch this one today, given the date. The Prelude to 9/11 is definitely the part I was most interested in, and this edit doesn't disappoint. It's pretty much a documentary with some re-enactments. Much more consistent in tone, drama and tension than..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"<div>This edit is a fascinating, in-depth look into a part of history that is somehow simultaneously over-emphasised and overlooked. The fusion of dramatic, historical, and first hand sources creates a compelling tension that draws you in and makes you anxious to find out what happens next (even though you already..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"Being a big fan of the original movie, it was really cool to see all of these new parts integrated into the film. Not all of them were improvements, though. Many of the deleted scenes were deleted for a reason, and while I wouldn't normally criticise an extended edition for..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"This is an effectively condensed version of the Day of the Doctor story. It refocuses the narrative onto the Zygon threat which makes it feel more like a regular episode with a cool gimmick rather than a special event. Despite a slightly awkward beginning the editing holds up nicely. It..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"This is a great personal take on RotJ that 100% achieves what it sets out to do. If you're like Jedi, but you're frustrated by some of the more child oriented aspects of it, this is definitely the edit for you. The important details of the movie all..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"I couldn't even tell that this movie was edited. There were no bad cuts, no dodgy audio and nothing felt out of place. The new voice acting is something I don't think has ever been done for a fanedit before and it's done incredibly well. It's a much better..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"Another killer Batman edit by Donkey! I don't know TDK by heart, so I wasn't aware of most of the changes while watching. In fact, looking back at the changelist, I didn't notice anything other then some memorable lines that were cut and the changes made to the parade..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"Just finished watching this edit, and I have to say it's pretty damn good. It does a brilliant job of shortening the movie without feeling like anything's missing, and the music choices are amazing especially in the finale, which is a two minute masterpiece. While I'm not the biggest..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"I usually don't like watching edits of movies I plan to edit in the future, but I made an exception for this one because I saw how much passion and effort went into it in the ITW thread. I have to say I enjoyed this edit a hell of..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"An absolutely fantastic edit! Music replacement is always tricky, most of the time there's an issue with silenced sound effects or with the music not quite lining up with the content of the edit, but there's none of that here. I think there were one or two lines that..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"This Edit is a great successor to Batman Forever Redbook addition, and I do believe that it's the best version of Batman & Robin that could exist, but unfortunately that still isn't a very good movie. I don't think there's much value to be gained from it except for seeing..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"I finally got round to watching this version after watching Split Unbreakable Glass a while ago, and I have to say this is definitely my favourite of the two. Maybe it's just because I like slower movies, but I felt the way UGS handled the mysteries in the story was..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"This is hands down the best fanedit I've seen so far. I've never hated Batman Forever, but it was never a movie I took very seriously. This edit changes that completely. The recolouring is very severe, but I can't say it isn't stylish. Once you get used to..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"This was a great concept, and I hope there are more opportunities to create superhero movies like this one. It's very well executed as well, with the flashbacks to Huntress' origin weaved in seamlessly, to the point that no one who didn't already know could tell you they were out..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"The was a great way to examine the trilogy, it was edited flawlessly and the intro and outro sequences were exceptionally well done, but I think Unbreakable in particular suffered from the amount cut. It might be spoiled by the fact that it's a contender for my favourite movie of..."
Reviewed by WilliamRedRobin
"This edit was incredibly well done from a technical perspective. The episodic structure felt very natural and the endings and title cards felt like they belonged in the movie. I'm pretty certain that you could show this to someone without telling them it was a fanedit and they wouldn't notice..."