Review Detail
9.9 5 10
Overall rating
9.7
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
9.0
Enjoyment
9.0
Problem Eliminator improves on the original. Some edits create big improvements (e.g. the shower on the boat is now enjoyable for the first time), some small. Some edits don't individually improve the film, but cumulatively they add up to a more streamlined and experience (e.g. cut the shot of M reading newspaper in car, though you still see her holding it in the following shot while listening to Tanner).
The edit loses a point in enjoyment for me because of frustrating parts in the original film, worst of all Silva derailing the Tube. Not the editor's fault, though leaving it in is an editing choice.
Problem Eliminator convincingly shows his editing skills, e.g. with the replaced music during the Shanghai elevator ride. With such eye for detail, I'd have loved to see a more rigorous edit to make this Bond even better.
The edit loses a point in enjoyment for me because of frustrating parts in the original film, worst of all Silva derailing the Tube. Not the editor's fault, though leaving it in is an editing choice.
Problem Eliminator convincingly shows his editing skills, e.g. with the replaced music during the Shanghai elevator ride. With such eye for detail, I'd have loved to see a more rigorous edit to make this Bond even better.
