Review Detail
9.0 14 10
(Updated: September 10, 2012)
Overall rating
6.0
Audio/Video Quality
N/A
Audio Editing
N/A
Visual Editing
N/A
Narrative
N/A
Enjoyment
6.0
Review by jokersmailbag — April 1, 2009 @ 4:50 pm
Interesting ideas for sure. The execution could be a lot better. It has quite a bit of problems, mostly audio for me. The new languages are a fantastic idea but really don’t come close to working, being clearly the non-english tracks played mostly backward. This causes strange drop offs at the ends (beginnings) of phrases.
Jar Jar is a bit more tolerable, but still far too many antics. And having him swear? Just doesn’t fit, IMO.
It was explained to me that this edit was made a few years ago and just now released officially here on FE. Some of the technical problems with this edit were more or less common to most fanedits at the time- so I have factored this in to consideration here. Still…
With so many good ideas, it would be great to see an improved version of this.
Interesting ideas for sure. The execution could be a lot better. It has quite a bit of problems, mostly audio for me. The new languages are a fantastic idea but really don’t come close to working, being clearly the non-english tracks played mostly backward. This causes strange drop offs at the ends (beginnings) of phrases.
Jar Jar is a bit more tolerable, but still far too many antics. And having him swear? Just doesn’t fit, IMO.
It was explained to me that this edit was made a few years ago and just now released officially here on FE. Some of the technical problems with this edit were more or less common to most fanedits at the time- so I have factored this in to consideration here. Still…
With so many good ideas, it would be great to see an improved version of this.
