Review Detail
9.5 19 10
(Updated: June 25, 2020)
Overall rating
9.8
Audio/Video Quality
9.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
10.0
Straight out the gate. This fan edit has its spot in the magnum opus fan edit universe.
The TV show is miles away better than the movie. But also it's not the same, it has a different story and acts as a sequel to the movie.
So let's go back to our review. This fan edit has been more globally comprehensive and attempts to reshape the theatrical version of Watchmen to more closely resemble the narrative structure and characterizations of the comic book.
Regarding the editing, I really enjoyed the new from “chapter” narrative structure of the original comic book. Also, the colors have been heavily changed to be more like in the comic book.
Finally, the Tales of the Black Freighter edited was well dispersed throughout the movie.
Fantastic job. Just wish there as an HD version :)
The TV show is miles away better than the movie. But also it's not the same, it has a different story and acts as a sequel to the movie.
So let's go back to our review. This fan edit has been more globally comprehensive and attempts to reshape the theatrical version of Watchmen to more closely resemble the narrative structure and characterizations of the comic book.
Regarding the editing, I really enjoyed the new from “chapter” narrative structure of the original comic book. Also, the colors have been heavily changed to be more like in the comic book.
Finally, the Tales of the Black Freighter edited was well dispersed throughout the movie.
Fantastic job. Just wish there as an HD version :)
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched
DVD
