Review Detail
(Updated: July 28, 2024)
Overall rating
7.6
Audio/Video Quality
6.0
Audio Editing
7.0
Video Editing
8.0
Narrative
9.0
Entertainment
9.0
User Review
Review
Audio/Video Quality 6/10
The picture is very pixelated, even for a 720p file.
Audio Editing 7/10
A couple distracting audio edits, but the majority of the edits are super clean.
The ending did feel a bit odd with the drop in audio volume when the monologue/speech was removed. I'd maybe adjust the levels to bring them a bit higher so the returning of the center channel is less noticeable. For the most part, solid audio editing.
Video Editing 8/10
A couple visual edits were noticeable, but the editor's audio editing mostly hid these cuts as to avoid feeling distracting.
Narrative 9/10
The narrative works and flows similar to the original without issues. One point removed as some of the intentions of characters are slightly lost in this edit, though it definitely does not create narrative conflicts.
Entertainment 9/10
I enjoyed the toned down approach that removed some of the more over the top and silly moments of this movie. I It's still a stylistic action film, but more grounded in itself.
Final thoughts
If the audio/video quality can be improved, this would be an IFDb approved edit. Good job on the editing!
The picture is very pixelated, even for a 720p file.
Audio Editing 7/10
A couple distracting audio edits, but the majority of the edits are super clean.
The ending did feel a bit odd with the drop in audio volume when the monologue/speech was removed. I'd maybe adjust the levels to bring them a bit higher so the returning of the center channel is less noticeable. For the most part, solid audio editing.
Video Editing 8/10
A couple visual edits were noticeable, but the editor's audio editing mostly hid these cuts as to avoid feeling distracting.
Narrative 9/10
The narrative works and flows similar to the original without issues. One point removed as some of the intentions of characters are slightly lost in this edit, though it definitely does not create narrative conflicts.
Entertainment 9/10
I enjoyed the toned down approach that removed some of the more over the top and silly moments of this movie. I It's still a stylistic action film, but more grounded in itself.
Final thoughts
If the audio/video quality can be improved, this would be an IFDb approved edit. Good job on the editing!
Format Watched
Digital
