Review Detail
10.0 9 10
Overall rating
10.0
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
10.0
It had been a long time since I'd seen Star Trek: Generations, but the memory in my mind was one of relative disappointment. Several qualities of the film had failed to live up to expectation, given it was a story about two legendary fictional characters sharing an adventure.
I showed Star Trek: TOS, the films, TNG to my girlfriend finally building up to Generations and I showed her this Fan Edit based on the description, reviews and score. We both really loved this edit.
The changes made by this editor have remarkably shaved off the abrasive edges of the piece, leaving a surprisingly enjoyable and poignant movie. It seems there was always a diamond in there somewhere and MightyAttackTribble found it and polished it.
It felt like after many years I got to enjoy a beautiful farewell to Admiral Kirk.
Data is also now understated instead of his original portrayal which felt uncharacteristically "zany"
I recommend this version very highly and a much improved alternative.
I showed Star Trek: TOS, the films, TNG to my girlfriend finally building up to Generations and I showed her this Fan Edit based on the description, reviews and score. We both really loved this edit.
The changes made by this editor have remarkably shaved off the abrasive edges of the piece, leaving a surprisingly enjoyable and poignant movie. It seems there was always a diamond in there somewhere and MightyAttackTribble found it and polished it.
It felt like after many years I got to enjoy a beautiful farewell to Admiral Kirk.
Data is also now understated instead of his original portrayal which felt uncharacteristically "zany"
I recommend this version very highly and a much improved alternative.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched
Digital
