Reviewed by gddgb
"Watched this on a discord watchparty with a few people, and everyone gave it 10/10. This was amazing from start to finish. Keep up the good work. I really don't have anything to criticize. Hilarious and enjoyable. Thanks for the work."
Reviewed by gddgb
"Big fan of the original. Big fan of the fanedit. Before I criticize, I need to gush.. This LOOKED amazing, and felt increditbly different than the original. I'm not sure if I haven't seen Fight Club since the bluray came out, but this felt much more visceral,..."
Reviewed by gddgb
"Nicely done! No eye-rolling lines throughout gets this movie closer to perfection. It's funny to see what some people think is good vs bad though. There were more things I would have liked moved/cut/mixed, and there were some things I would have left in (like Alfred's..."
Reviewed by gddgb
"Man this was a fun one! The editing was flawless, audio and all. No obvious cuts. As far as de-exaggerating the characters, Ryantology did a great job. No dumb lines, and everyone feels like an actual person. There were still a couple cheesy or purposely..."
Reviewed by gddgb
"What can I say? This was a great movie, and had not the slightest evidence of an amateur edit. The best review I can give is my score of the original vs the fanedit. (6.5 original vs 8.0 fanedit) Original: 1.5 / 2 directing & technical aspect 1..."
Reviewed by gddgb
"Yes, man. This is what a fanedit should be. This was engrossing from beginning to end, and edited beautifully. I don't know how much you moved around to create the flashbacks (if anything), but it worked perfectly. The video looks better than some "HD" fanedits which is..."
Reviewed by gddgb
"I watched this a few days after watching Ranger613's "Fall of Sherlock" edit. From a narrative perspective, this one feels more like 2 separate episodes fused together than a movie. It may be because only two episodes were used, because the Moriarty arc was the absolute perfect arc..."
Reviewed by gddgb
"I only watched the roadshow version in the theater before seeing this cut, so I am comparing this to a 3+ hour version of the movie, with an intermission, shot in 2.76:1 ratio on Ultra Panavision 70mm film. (film snob much?) The point is it was purposely edited to be..."
Reviewed by gddgb
"Everything about the Moriarty arc was done better than the original in this edit. There were only a couple edits I thought could look a little better. Overall, this was a great edit, and very enjoyable."